ESG Telegraph
  • Home
  • Latest News
  • Environment
  • Companies
  • Investors
  • Governance
  • Markets
  • Social
  • Regulators
  • Sustainable Finance
Featured Posts
    • Companies
    M&S tries to address criticism of rebuilding plans for flagship store
    • August 19, 2022
    • Latest News
    Investors fret over durability of summer rally in US markets
    • August 19, 2022
    • Companies
    Privatising water was never going to work
    • August 19, 2022
    • Latest News
    Cineworld prepares for US bankruptcy filing
    • August 19, 2022
    • Companies
    WWE: body-slammed boss dives out as new champ grapples sale rumours
    • August 19, 2022
Featured Categories
Belarussia
View Posts
Companies
View Posts
Energy
View Posts
Environment
View Posts
Food
View Posts
Governance
View Posts
Health
View Posts
Investors
View Posts
Latest News
View Posts
Markets
View Posts
Potash
View Posts
Regulators
View Posts
Russsia
View Posts
Social
View Posts
Supply Chain
View Posts
Sustainable Finance
View Posts
Technology
View Posts
Uncategorized
View Posts
ESG Telegraph ESG Telegraph
7K
9K
4K
1K
ESG Telegraph ESG Telegraph
  • Home
  • Latest News
  • Environment
  • Companies
  • Investors
  • Governance
  • Markets
  • Social
  • Regulators
  • Sustainable Finance
  • Latest News

Mike Lynch loses fraud claim brought by HPE over 2011 sale of Autonomy

  • January 28, 2022
  • Staff
Total
0
Shares
0
0
0

Mike Lynch, the billionaire founder of software maker Autonomy, has lost a fraud claim brought by Hewlett Packard Enterprise following its $11bn takeover of one of Britain’s best-known tech companies more than a decade ago.

Lynch and Sushovan Hussain, Autonomy’s former chief financial officer, were sued in London’s High Court by HPE for allegedly manipulating the software group’s accounts, leading the Silicon Valley company to pay an extra $5bn when it acquired Autonomy in 2011.

Two years after the trial ended, Mr Justice Robert Hildyard ruled on Friday that HPE had “substantially succeeded” in its claim against Lynch although the amount of damages would be “considerably less” than HPE had claimed. His full ruling will be handed down at a later date.

Lynch and Hussain both denied the allegations and any wrongdoing during the nine-month trial.

The ruling in the civil lawsuit is a major blow to Lynch, who is facing extradition to the US to face criminal charges over Autonomy’s sale. He faces allegations that include 14 counts of conspiracy and fraud.

A London court ruled in July that he should be extradited to the US. The UK home secretary, Priti Patel, has until midnight on Friday to decide whether to approve the extradition and can now take the ruling from Hildyard into consideration.

If she approves the extradition, Lynch could then appeal against the decision in a legal process that could run for years.

The conclusions reached by Hildyard are significant because the civil lawsuit in London covered the same allegations and heard from some of the same witnesses due to testify in the US criminal trial.

Hildyard, who read a summary of his conclusions to a High Court hearing on Friday, found that a hardware reselling programme by Autonomy was there to cover shortfalls in software revenue, was “dishonest” and that the defendants were “well aware of this”.

These “lossmaking transactions were not commercially justified on any basis”, the judge said of the hardware reselling programme, and were concealed because their revelation would have exposed that Autonomy’s software business was not generating the accelerating profits “which heavily influenced its price”.

He found that HPE relied on what was said about Autonomy’s revenue in the accounting material and was induced to pay $11bn for Autonomy.

Lynch and Hussain were aware of Autonomy’s sales to value added resellers (VAR) intended to make up shortfalls in the software business and Autonomy’s accountants, Deloitte, “did not see the full picture”, he added.

The judge said he would decide compensation at a later stage but said he would expect the quantum of damages to be “substantially less” than the $5bn being sought by the US group.

In the High Court trial, HPE accused Lynch of telling “lie after lie” and being “unreliable” in the witness box. During the trial, Lynch accused HPE of bringing the lawsuit because its board had suffered “buyer’s remorse”. Meg Whitman, HP’s chief executive at the time of the deal, saw Autonomy as a “headache” because the company was “floundering and she was firefighting on many fronts”, he claimed.

HPE lodged the lawsuit after its decision to take an $8bn impairment charge on the deal in November 2012, which it blamed on “improprieties” by the Autonomy team.

In September 2020, a ruling by the Financial Reporting Council ordered Deloitte to pay a record £15m fine, plus legal costs of £5.6m, for serious misconduct over its audit of Autonomy.

HPE said in a statement on Friday: “Dr Lynch and Hussain defrauded and deliberately misled the market and Hewlett Packard. HPE is pleased the judge has held them accountable.”

Kelwin Nicholls, a lawyer at Clifford Chance representing Lynch, said in a statement that the decision was “disappointing” and that his client plans to file an appeal.

“We note the judge’s concerns over the reliability of some of HP’s witnesses,” Nicholls said. “We also note the judge’s expectation that any loss suffered by HP will be substantially less than the $5bn claimed.”

Total
0
Shares
Share 0
Tweet 0
Pin it 0
You May Also Like
Read More
  • Latest News

Investors fret over durability of summer rally in US markets

  • Staff
  • August 19, 2022
Read More
  • Latest News

Cineworld prepares for US bankruptcy filing

  • Staff
  • August 19, 2022
Read More
  • Latest News

UK health body calls for upgrade to sewage system as beaches close

  • Staff
  • August 19, 2022
Read More
  • Latest News

Italy election frontrunner Giorgia Meloni says she will not put Covid funds at risk

  • Staff
  • August 19, 2022
Read More
  • Latest News

Air travel chaos begins to ease but is there more trouble on the horizon?

  • Staff
  • August 19, 2022
Read More
  • Latest News

Starling Bank’s Anne Boden: ‘I was ashamed to be a banker’

  • Staff
  • August 19, 2022
Read More
  • Latest News

Trump’s turmoil poses a conundrum for Republicans

  • Staff
  • August 19, 2022
Read More
  • Latest News

Chinese tycoon Xiao Jianhua sentenced to 13 years in jail for financial crimes

  • Staff
  • August 19, 2022

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Featured Posts
  • 1
    M&S tries to address criticism of rebuilding plans for flagship store
    • August 19, 2022
  • 2
    Investors fret over durability of summer rally in US markets
    • August 19, 2022
  • 3
    Privatising water was never going to work
    • August 19, 2022
  • 4
    Cineworld prepares for US bankruptcy filing
    • August 19, 2022
  • 5
    WWE: body-slammed boss dives out as new champ grapples sale rumours
    • August 19, 2022
Recent Posts
  • Net zero targets: Ask what you can do for your country . . . 
    • August 19, 2022
  • UK health body calls for upgrade to sewage system as beaches close
    • August 19, 2022
  • How Tiger Global withdrew its claws when the tech bubble burst
    • August 19, 2022

Sign Up for Our Newsletters

Subscribe now to our newsletter

ESG Telegraph
  • Home
  • Privacy Policy
  • Guest Post
  • Contact

Input your search keywords and press Enter.